Appetizers

  • Pickle Bill’s Famous Deep Fried Pickles – $7.99
  • Calamari – Lightly floured & deep fried topped with shredded cheese- $12.99
  • Coconut Shrimp – with plum sauce -$8.99
  • Shrimp Cocktail – chopped celery, tangy cocktail sauce, fresh lemons, saltines. $7.99 – for (2) $13.99
  • Steamed Mussels – 1 lb. with white wine, butter, garlic, crusty brad – $11.99
  • Bucket of Mussels and Clams – Sautéed in white wine and garlic butter – $13.99
  • Oysters on the Half Shell – $2.50 each or ½ dozen $14.99
  • Lobster Dip served with house made tortilla chips -$9.99
  • Steamed Clams – One dozen middle-neck clams served with natural broth and drawn butter – $14.99

Soups & Salads

  • New England clam chowder – Cup – $5.99 Bowl $7.99
  • Lobster Bisque – Cup -$6.99 Bowl $8.99
  • Soup & Salad – $11.99
  • Dinner Salad – $9.95 – add Chicken, Shrimp or Blackened Salmon for add’l $8.00
  • Cobb Salad – Chicken, tomato, bacon, bleu cheese, avocado & egg – $15.99
    • Add Cocktail Shrimp or Salmon – add $8.00

Entrees

Prime Rib of Beef
12 oz. cut – $29.99
Captain’s Cut – (16 oz.) – $36.99
All You Can Eat – $44.99

Lake Erie Walleye
Battered
Dinner – $24.99
All You Can Eat (fried only) – $28.99

Lake Erie Perch
Battered
Dinner – $24.99
All You Can Eat – $28.99

Shrimp
Deep Fried Dinner – $19.99
Coconut Breaded Dinner – $21.99
One Pound Peel-n-Eat (chilled) – $21.99
All You Can Eat – $24.99

Alaskan Snow Crab
One Pound Dinner – $29.99
Two Pound Dinner – $49.99
Three Pound Dinner – $53.99
All You Can Eat – $59.99

Whole Maine Lobsters
Fresh from Rockport, Maine
1lb. – $33.99 1 ¼ lb. – $37.99 1 ½ lb. – $40.99 2 lb. – $49.99
Larger Lobsters Available
All You Can Eat – $160.00

Alaskan King Crab
Served with Drawn Butter – One pound – $58.99 | One and a half pound – $79.99

New England Shore Dinner
One-half pound Alaskan Snow Crab, Jumbo Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Andouille Sausage, Fresh Corn and Red Skin Potatoes, seasoned with Old Bay, served with Cole Slaw! A feast!
$37.99 for one $70.00 for two

Entrees are served with mixed green salad or coleslaw, choice of a side dish and our
famous fried dough and cinnamon butter.

Add a second ALL YOU CAN EAT item to the highest priced item for an additional $9.99
ALL YOU CAN EAT prices are per person. PLEASE NO SHARING OR DOGGIE BAGS

*Not responsible for beef cooked medium well or well done*
**We cannot guarantee our fish to be boneless**
***Consuming raw or uncooked meats, poultry, seafood or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness***
** Plate sharing charge of $7.00 includes additional side & cole slaw or pasta salad ** (excludes All You Can Eat)
*GRATUITY NOT INCLUDED* 18% service charge will be added to parties of 8 or more. 
*All menu items and prices are subject to change at any time without notice.*

Shellfish

  • Seafood Sensation – ½ lb. king crab, ½ lb. snow crab, 1lb whole Maine lobster, corn on the cob – $51.99
  • Twin Lobster Tails – (Two 5oz. tails) oven broiled, served with drawn butter – $43.99
  • Broiled Scampi – in lemon garlic butter – $27.99
  • Fine Kettle of Fish – Whole Maine Lobster, ½ lb. Snow Crab, Clams, Mussels & Corn on the cob
    • 1 lb Lobster – $46.99
    • 1 ¼ lbs. – $50.99
    • 1 ½ lbs. – $55.99
    • 5 ounce lobster tail – $46.99

8-oz. Top Sirloin Steak Combos

  • Steak and Fries – Grilled 10-oz. Top Sirloin Steak, French Fries, beefsteak tomato – $22.99
  • Steak n’ Scampi – four scampied shrimp – $33.99
  • Steak n’Snow Crab – $37.99
  • Steak n’ Lobster – 5 oz. broiled lobster tail – $41.99
  • Steak n’King – 1/2 lb. King Crab -$48.99

    House Specials

  • Broiled Seafood Platter – $33.99
    • ½ lb. snow crab, Atlantic cod, shrimp and clams broiled in garlic, herbs and white wine
  • Whiskey Island Chicken – $16.99
    • Breast of chicken topped with bacon, two cheeses and BBQ sauce
  • Seafood Sampler – Battered walleye, perch and shrimp – $26.99
  • North Atlantic Salmon – Grilled over cherry wood – $23.99
  • Grilled Lake Erie Walleye – $24.99
  • Fish-n-Chips – 1/2 pound of our hand battered cod $15.99
  • All-You-Can-Eat Fish-n-Chips – $20.99
  • Perch Platter – Family Style (served with All-You-Can-Eat French Fries and Cole Slaw) Serves 4 – $69.99 | Serves 6 – $99.99 | Serves 8 – $129.99

Sides—Spicy Red Beans & Rice*French Fries*Red Skin Potatoes*Corn On the Cobb

 

Sandwiches

(served with french fries)

  • Pickle Bill’s Cheeseburger – $12.99
    • Grilled over cherry wood and topped with all the fixins
  • Lake Erie Walleye Fish Sandwich – Battered and deep-fried golden, tartar sauce – $14.99
  • Philly Cheesesteak – Prime Rib of Beef topped with provolone cheese, peppers & onions – $14.99
  • Captain Hook Fish Sandwich – Lake Erie Perch battered and fried golden, tartar sauce – $14.99.
  • Veggie Burger – Grilled and served just like our regular burger – $12.99

Children’s Menu

(ages 10 and under)

  • Crab Legs – $16.99
  • Prime Rib – $15.99
  • Hot Dog – $4.99
  • Chicken Tenders – $8.99
  • Deep Fried Shrimp – $8.99
  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich – $4.99
  • Cheeseburger – $5.99

Served with choice of one side dish and beverage.

 

Add-On’s

    • 5 oz. Lobster Tail – $24.99
    • Fried Shrimp (half dozen) – $7.99
    • Coconut Shrimp (half dozen) – $8.99
    • Sautéed Mushrooms – $2.50
    • Sautéed Onions – $2.50
    • 1/2 lb. Snow Crab – $16.99
    • 18% service charge will be added to parties of 8 or more

Now Serving Clambakes! For a Limited Time Only

All clambakes are served with savory broth, a dozen flavorful, middle-neck clams, a cup of creamy clam chowder or luscious lobster bisque, fresh corn on the cob, a seasonal sweet potato, fresh melon and our famous fried dough with cinnamon-honey butter. YUM!

Clambake Season ON at Pickle Bills

Chicken Bake featuring an oven-roasted half chicken – $25.99

Crab Bake with one-pound of Alaskan snow crab legs – $41.99

Perch Bake prepared with batter and fried – $28.99

Lobster Bake featuring our one-pound, whole Maine Lobster – $46.99

Extra Dozen Clams – one dozen middle-neck clams served with natural broth and drawn butter – $14.99

Fine Kettle of Fish – one-pound, whole Maine lobster, ½ lb. snow crab, clams, mussels & corn on the cob – $45.99

Seafood Sensation –  ½ lb. king crab, ½ lb. snow crab, one-pound whole Maine lobster, corn on the cob – $49.99